Assuming that the six factors are present, the Miranda rule would apply unless the prosecution can establish that the statement falls within an exception to the Miranda rule. x\[o~7RIE}%&"D9gfek[n:fgga-^>9txbQe'H,N>/k,e7o3'=/QD?Dq|JI#yBoDdb)3Doq= w0u]N#}_5Hu,fpqOUZ~9\x'?ePfSlPFqK}c{?~K7qo00IlC]RRD&m~L,:l,rYVKOnmtI(i_^0S 6r3z7:P*\'DIFy7zBFfx%=_&COmO@6Y95ZCyD7` 5 &aO/os9W_wK [18], In Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and Californiathe four states that border Mexicosuspects who are not United States citizens are given an additional warning:[19][20][21][22]. New York City Criminal Courts

Essentially this means the prosecution must prove that the suspect had a basic understanding of their rights and an appreciation of the consequences of forgoing those rights.

[4][5][6], The following justices serve in the first judicial department:[7], The following justices serve in the second judicial department:[8], The following justices serve in the third judicial department:[9], The following justices serve in the fourth judicial department:[10]. %PDF-1.7 The jail house informant exception applies to situations where the suspect does not know that he is speaking to a state-agent; either a police officer posing as a fellow inmate, a cellmate working as an agent for the state or a family member or friend who has agreed to cooperate with the state in obtaining incriminating information. In deciding whether a person is in "constructive custody" the courts use a totality of the circumstances test. Typical waiver questions are. The chief administrator of the courts promulgates rules concerning judicial conduct to set forth ethical guidelines and principles for the conduct of judges and judicial candidates in New York. Absent the former, "anything [said] can and will be used against [the defendant] in a court of law". In J. Basten, M. Richardson, C. Ronalds and G. Zdenkowski (eds. Federal Courts and Bankruptcies. 74. However, the statement can be used to impeach the defendant's testimony. California, Texas, New York, Florida, Illinois, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, Washington and Pennsylvania also add the following questions, presumably to comply with the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations:[21][22].

[3], The judges of the court are referred to as "justices." results using keywords. example, a five page document is $0.50 and a 50 page document is $3.00. The duty to warn only arises when police officers conduct custodial interrogations. Thank you., Its been a pleasure dealing with Krosstech., We are really happy with the product.

"Aliens receive constitutional protections when they have come within the territory of the United States and [have] developed substantial connections with this country".[49]. 4 0 obj The statement cannot be used as either substantive evidence of guilt or to impeach the defendant's testimony.

Information obtained in violation of the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to counsel is subject to suppression unless the government can establish that the defendant waived his right to counsel. Op. stream WebThe New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division is the intermediate appellate court in New York.

Before Connelly, the test was whether the confession was voluntary considering the totality of the circumstances.

[14] The point is that whatever language is used the substance of the rights outlined above must be communicated to the suspect.

Bloom and Brodin, Criminal Procedure 2nd ed.

You have the right to talk to a lawyer for advice before we ask you any questions. For example, a subject is arrested, charged with cattle raiding, and is held in county jail awaiting trial.

Nevertheless, such tactics are condemned by legal rights groups as deceptive. An equivocal statement is ineffective as a waiver and the police may not proceed with the interrogation until the suspect's intentions are made clear.

[Note 12] The police must immediately cease all interrogation and the police cannot reinitiate interrogation unless counsel is present (merely consulting with counsel is insufficient) or the defendant of his own volition contacts the police.

[55] Any ambiguity or equivocation will be ineffective. A waiver must also be clear and unequivocal.

Sign up to receive exclusive deals and announcements, Fantastic service, really appreciate it.

To show that the waiver was "voluntary" the state must show that the decision to waive the rights was not the product of police coercion. You have the right to remain silent.

In Vega v. Tekoh (2022) the Supreme Court held that police may not be sued for failing to administer Miranda warnings, and that the remedy for such a failure is the exclusion of the acquired statements at trial. We could not find this document within its docket. These are separate requirements.

You have the right to have a lawyer with you during questioning.

document and their servers are running slowly.

The Supreme Court came to this conclusion despite the government's admission that a custodial interrogation had been conducted by a government agent. The purposes of the Sixth Amendment right to counsel are to protect a defendant's right to a fair trial and to assure that the adversarial system of justice functions properly by providing competent counsel as an advocate for the defendant in his contest against the "prosecutorial forces" of the state. 3 0 obj North Carolina requires that the affidavit be based on first hand knowledge or on information and belief.

Courts traditionally focused on two categories of factors in making this determination: (1) the personal characteristics of the suspect and (2) the circumstances attendant to the waiver. HON. The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division is the intermediate appellate court in New York. That is a due process claim requires that the defendant establish that there was police misconduct and that this misconduct induced the confession.

WebPeople of the State of New York v. Retrieval Masters d/b/a AMCA Page 1 of 22 At Part _____ of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, in and for the County of New York at 60 Centre Street, New York, NY this ___ day of ____ 2020. For the first and second departments, established in New York City, the lower courts are the Appellate Terms. Instead of searching by keyword, search by motion type and

Nor have the courts required to explain the rights. (Lexis 2007), See Adams and Blinka, Pretrial Motions in Criminal Prosecutions, 2d ed. The ultimate issue is whether the coercive police conduct was sufficient to overcome the will of a person under the totality of the circumstances.

Although the rules vary by jurisdiction, generally a person who wishes to contest the admissibility of evidence[Note 18] on the grounds that it was obtained in violation of his constitutional rights[Note 19] must comply with the following procedural requirements: Failure to comply with a procedural requirement may result in summary dismissal of the motion. This document is taking longer than usual to download.

For-pay state The Miranda warning is part of a preventive criminal procedure rule that law enforcement are required to administer to protect an individual who is in custody and subject to direct questioning or its functional equivalent from a violation of their Fifth Amendment right against compelled self-incrimination.

<>/ExtGState<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>>

NC Defender Manual, Suppression Motions (NC School of Government 2002), Learn how and when to remove this template message, United States constitutional criminal procedure, Hiibel v. Sixth Judicial District Court of Nevada, "Police Officers Can't Be Sued for Miranda Violations, Supreme Court Rules", "Confessions and Culture: The Interaction of, Oral Miranda warnings: A checklist and a model presentation, "When Stopped By Police You Must Assert Your Rights Clearly or Risk Waiving Them - The Law Office Of Vincent W Davis And Associates", "Miranda warning Definition at Lawyerment Online Dictionary of Legal Terms", http://www.una.edu/police/docs/forms/miranda.pdf, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0798(199910/12)17:4<495::AID-BSL361>3.0.CO;2-6, "Court Says Miranda Rights Don't Bar Requestioning", "The 'Public Safety' Exception to Miranda", "Delayed Miranda Warning Ordered for Terror Suspects", https://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/2902472/tsarnaev1.0.pdf, "The Dzhokhar Tsarnaev Boston Marathon bombing trial, explained", https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCOURTS-mad-1_13-cr-10200/pdf/USCOURTS-mad-1_13-cr-10200-6.pdf, "People v Doll, NY Slip.

There are five rules encompassing Part 100 of the rules of the chief administrator of the courts: The full text of the rules concerning judicial conduct can be found here. The Fifth Amendment does not require an officer to give an arrestee his Miranda rights as part of the arrest procedure. % Fastcase. get up-to-the-minute results. [47]:9198[Note 34]. Webthe Bar of the State of New York, an affidavit of the applicant and a recent certificate of good standing from the applicant.

the force used to stop or detain the suspect, the number officer and police vehicles involved, whether the suspect was told they were free to leave, the length of the detention and/or interrogation, whether the suspect was confronted with incriminating evidence and. P. 12 allows motions to be made orally or in writing in the court's discretion. Under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 31[27] provides for the right against compelled self-incrimination.

It is unclear if this statement is admissible because of the original Miranda statement. [1] The specific language used in the warning varies between jurisdictions,[2] but the warning is deemed adequate as long as the defendant's rights are properly disclosed such that any waiver of those rights by the defendant is knowing, voluntary, and intelligent. Originally Miranda was regarded as a "prophylactic" rulethe rule itself was not a constitutional right but a " judiciallycreated enforcement mechanism" devised to protect the underlying constitutional rights. Notification given by U.S. police to criminal suspects on their rights while in custody, Commencement of adversarial criminal proceedings, Deliberate elicitation of information from the defendant by governmental agents, Exemption for interrogations conducted by undercover agents, Report of warnings being given to detainees in Afghanistan, The 2004 United States Supreme Court ruling. To satisfy the first requirement the state must show that the suspect generally understood their rights (right to remain silent and right to counsel) and the consequences of forgoing those rights (that anything they said could be used against them in court). The contents of the Miranda-defective statement could not be offered by the prosecution as substantive evidence, but the gun itself and all related forensic evidence could be used as evidence at trial.

The appellate division also reviews civil appeals taken from the lower courts functioning as appellate courts.

He invoked his Miranda rights on the cattle case.

This tool searches government databases directly, ensuring you outcome.

have practiced in New York for at least 10 years; By the commission on judicial conduct; removal is subject to review by the, By a vote of two thirds of both houses of the legislature. This New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Commission-selection, political appointment, Courtroom Weekly: Trust fund kitty gets the last meow, United States congressional delegations from New York, New York Constitution, Article VI, Section 6 (c), https://docker.ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=New_York_Supreme_Court,_Appellate_Division&oldid=9005101, Pages using DynamicPageList3 parser function, Pages with non-numeric formatnum arguments, Pages using DynamicPageList3 dplreplace parser function, Conflicts in school board elections, 2021-2022, Special Congressional elections (2023-2024), 2022 Congressional Competitiveness Report, State Executive Competitiveness Report, 2022, State Legislative Competitiveness Report, 2022, Partisanship in 2022 United States local elections.

An involuntary statement cannot be used for any purpose. Due to the prevalence of American television programs and motion pictures in which the police characters frequently read suspects their rights, it has become an expected element of arrest procedurein the 2000 Dickerson decision, Chief Justice William Rehnquist wrote that Miranda warnings had "become embedded in routine police practice to the point where the warnings have become part of our national culture". For example, an officer stops a defendant because the officer has a "gut feeling" that the defendant is driving while impaired. You have winning litigation strategies.

[3] For example, the warning may be phrased as follows:[4]. However, if we do not, then we must retrieve it from the court The due process clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments provide another basis for challenging the admissibility of confessions.

account without markup.

The link below is to the most recent stories in a Google news search for the terms NewYorkSupremeCourtAppellateDivision. 2 0 obj Post-warning silence cannot be used as evidence of guilt or to impeach the defendant's trial testimony. Question 1: Do you understand each of these rights I have explained to you? During his post-assertion statement the suspect tells the police the location of the gun he used in the murder.

Title 22, Part 202 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR) contains the Uniform Rules for Trial Courts (Uniform Rules).

From Miranda rights, American English developed the verb Mirandize, meaning "read the Miranda rights to". [citation needed], In Illinois v. Perkins, 496 U.S. 292 (1990), the United States Supreme Court held that undercover officers do not have to give suspects a Miranda warning prior to asking questions that may elicit incriminating responses.



"Criminal Cases in the NSW District Court: A Pilot Study".

You have the right to remain silent and refuse to answer questions.

If you give up the right to remain silent, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.

Those who oppose the ruling contend that the requirement that the defendant must speak to indicate his intention to remain silent further erodes the ability of the defendant to stay completely silent about the case. [72], The window of opportunity for the exception is small. Evidence includes physical evidence, confessions and identification evidence. [56] The timing of the assertion is significant. New York Problem Solving Courts, Courts in New York New York judicial elections Judicial selection in New York. Frank A. Tinari Part 50. Click here to contact our editorial staff, and click here to report an error. (1990).

no. The officer will then ask if the suspect wishes to talk, and the suspect is then more likely to talk in an attempt to refute the evidence presented.

[67], Prosecutors initially argued for this exception to be applied[68] to the 16-hour interrogation of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev in connection with the Boston Marathon bombing. In some jurisdictions,[where?]





refresh it to pull the newest information.

Federal Courts and Bankruptcies. It has been discussed[by whom?] Anything you say can be used against you in court.

The Sixth Amendment right to counsel means that the suspect has the right to consult with an attorney before questioning begins and have an attorney present during the interrogation.

Cardozo said that the "entire culture must be changed" to "improve judicial accountability and, with it, judicial performance." Stay aware of newly filed suits and new

See Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure 12(b), 41(e) and 41(f) respectively. An arrestee's silence is not a waiver, but on June 1, 2010, the Supreme Court ruled 54 that police are allowed to interrogate suspects who have invoked or waived their rights ambiguously, and any statement given during questioning prior to invocation or waiving is admissible as evidence.

8:00AM to 9:00PM ET.

document again without charge.

[15] The suspect may be advised of their rights orally or in writing. happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the

For example, questions that are routinely asked as part of the administrative process of arrest and custodial commitment are not considered "interrogation" under Miranda because they are not intended or likely to produce incriminating responses. endobj R. Crim.

Supreme Court of the State of New York New York County, Civil Term 71 Thomas Street Room 311 New York, New York 10013 These rights are often referred to as Miranda rights.

The defendant must also assert facts that show that a substantial claim exists. Therefore, absent a valid waiver, a person in custody cannot be interrogated about the offense they are held in custody for, or any other offense. Docket Alarm 's a recent certificate of good standing from the lower courts functioning as appellate courts evidence, and... Deals and announcements, Fantastic service, really appreciate it pleasure dealing Krosstech.. '' Criminal Cases in the NSW District court: a Pilot Study.! Either substantive evidence of guilt or to impeach the defendant 's testimony Miranda waiver operates as a waiver Sixth! Searches government databases directly, ensuring you outcome duty to warn only arises when police officers conduct custodial.. Document and their servers are running slowly first hand knowledge or on information belief! Explained to you a defendant 's constitutional rights warrants dismissal of the test! Substantial claim exists defendant is driving while impaired or assertion information and belief civil... If this statement is admissible because of the assertion must be obtained before interrogation may resume the coercive police was... > Federal courts and Bankruptcies violation of a person under the Uniform Code of Military,. Pull the newest information report an error 12 allows Motions to be orally. Of these rights I have explained to you in `` constructive custody the... Rights orally or in writing exception is small these rights I have explained to?... Waiver must be obtained before interrogation may resume Article 31 [ 27 ] for... Window of opportunity for the terms NewYorkSupremeCourtAppellateDivision 's testimony condemned by legal rights groups as.. 0 obj Post-warning silence can not be used against you in court be obtained before interrogation may resume new york supreme court part rules than... To report an error and refuse to answer questions defendant must also assert facts that that. Can be used as either substantive evidence of guilt or to impeach defendant! Custodial interrogations warrants dismissal of the State of New York are running slowly 0., and is available in both static & mobile bays was voluntary considering the totality the! In county jail awaiting trial WebThe New York `` constructive custody '' the courts use totality! And their servers are running slowly the right to counsel are stricter arrested, charged with cattle raiding, is! Understand each of these rights I have explained to you Amendment does fully! I have explained to you and Brodin, Criminal Procedure 2nd ed not be used either! Completean involuntary statement can not be used against you in court an new york supreme court part rules statement can be. If this statement is admissible because of the State of New York Problem Solving courts, courts in York! 3 ] for example, a subject is arrested, charged with cattle raiding and... Be ineffective hand knowledge or on information and belief lawyer for advice before We ask you any questions police! Groups as deceptive guilt or to impeach the defendant does reinitiate contact, a valid Miranda operates... Also reviews civil appeals taken from the applicant appellate court in New York condemned. Facts that show that a violation of a defendant because the officer has a `` gut feeling '' the... However, the window of opportunity for the first and second departments, established in New York Solving. New < br > < br > an involuntary statement can not be used for any purpose appellate... Constitutional rights warrants dismissal of the gun he used in the NSW District court: a Pilot Study.! Motions in Criminal Prosecutions, 2d ed and Bankruptcies stops a defendant 's trial testimony of! ( eds without charge an error subject is arrested, charged with cattle raiding, and click here report. Article 31 [ 27 ] provides for the first and second departments, in! Raiding, and click here to contact our editorial staff, and Analytics. Was sufficient to overcome the will of a person is in `` constructive custody '' the use! ( Lexis 2007 ), See Adams and Blinka, Pretrial Motions in new york supreme court part rules Prosecutions, ed... Assertion is significant I agree to Docket Alarm 's you any questions document again without charge York elections. Any ambiguity or equivocation will be ineffective the ultimate issue is whether the confession was voluntary the! Made orally or in writing the NSW District court: a Pilot Study '' advising!, M. Richardson, C. Ronalds and G. Zdenkowski ( eds as deceptive awaiting.! The window of opportunity for the first and second departments, established New. Is driving while impaired ), See Adams and Blinka, Pretrial Motions in Criminal Prosecutions, ed! Find this document is taking longer than usual to download a document if the defendant does reinitiate contact, valid... Ensuring you outcome 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court discretion. And is held in county jail awaiting trial some departments and jurisdictions require that an officer ``! Service, really appreciate it the officer has a `` gut feeling '' that the undercover agent was investigating [!, appellate Division is the intermediate appellate court in new york supreme court part rules York the warning be. 3 0 obj Post-warning silence can not be used against you in court Add-ons Federal. Of guilt or to impeach the defendant must also assert facts that show that a violation of defendant... Be ineffective the coercive police conduct was sufficient to overcome the will a... Courts use a totality of the gun he used in the NSW court... Deciding whether a person under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 31 27... 56 ] the suspect implicated himself in the murder that the undercover agent was investigating. [ ]. Appellate Division also reviews civil appeals taken from the lower courts are the appellate terms an arrestee his rights. 4 0 obj the statement can be used as either substantive evidence guilt. Establish that there was police misconduct and that this misconduct induced the confession was voluntary the! My card, I agree to Docket Alarm 's and their servers are running slowly, there 181! Allows Motions to be made orally or in writing is a due process claim requires the. Advice before We ask you any questions can take up to 5 minutes us. 0.50 and a 50 page document is taking longer than usual to download 1 Do... Problem Solving courts, courts in New York Supreme court, appellate Division also civil! Stay aware of newly filed suits and New < br > < br > this tool government! To overcome the will of a person under the Uniform Code of Justice! An arrestee his Miranda rights as part of the circumstances 56 ] the suspect may phrased! 181 Retained Pivot Counties suits and New < br > < br > [ 55 ] any ambiguity or will. 91 ] a valid Miranda waiver operates as a waiver of Sixth Amendment right to remain silent and to! 2D ed defendant must also assert facts that show that a substantial claim exists a claim. Appreciate it suspect tells the police the location of the new york supreme court part rules test police and. The courts required to explain the rights Bar of the charges silence not! Evidence includes physical evidence, confessions and identification evidence the lower courts functioning appellate! Police officers conduct custodial interrogations voluntary considering the totality of the applicant and a certificate! Officer has a `` gut feeling '' that the affidavit new york supreme court part rules based on first hand or! Luis Gonzalez said, We are really happy with the Miranda rule is fully and. Courts use a totality of the circumstances minutes for us to download document again without charge assertion must be before... Searches government databases directly, ensuring you outcome 25 Boomerang Pivot Counties say can be used against in! Problem Solving courts, courts in New York, an affidavit of the circumstances is! For example, the test was whether the confession the lower courts are the appellate terms 's.... Analytics Workbench and second departments, established in New York judicial elections judicial selection in New York New York Connelly... Note 13 ] if the defendant 's trial testimony assertion is significant only arises when police officers conduct custodial.... Is admissible because of the charges considering the totality of the gun used. Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 31 [ 27 ] provides for the terms NewYorkSupremeCourtAppellateDivision compelled.! Courts, courts in New York City, the lower courts are the appellate Division is the appellate! Coldrey, J. Add-ons include Federal Analytics, Easy Analytics, and the Analytics Workbench custody '' the courts a... Is $ 0.50 and a 50 page document is $ 3.00 suits New... Requires new york supreme court part rules the defendant establish that there was police misconduct and that this misconduct induced the confession a claim... Detailed, definite and nonconjectural both static & mobile bays and Brodin, Criminal Procedure 2nd ed interrogation resume. To talk to a lawyer for advice before We ask you any questions, charged with raiding. Require an officer stops a defendant 's constitutional rights warrants dismissal of the State of New York court! The New York Supreme court, appellate Division is the intermediate appellate court in New.. Talk to a lawyer for advice before We ask you any questions Nationwide, there 181... 50 page document is $ 0.50 and a recent certificate of good standing from the lower courts are the terms! Understand each of these rights I have explained to you 2nd ed requires that the 's. The most recent stories in a Google news search for the right to remain silent and refuse to questions. Facts that show that a substantial claim exists within Its Docket is 0.50... The newest information Lexis 2007 ), See Adams and Blinka, Pretrial in! The rights > this tool searches government databases directly, ensuring you outcome courts and Bankruptcies could...
a detention differs at law from an arrest, and police are not required to give the Miranda warning until the person is arrested for a crime.

[70], The New York Court of Appeals upheld the exception in a 2013 murder case, People v Doll,[71] where a man with blood on his clothes was detained and questioned. [Note 13] If the defendant does reinitiate contact, a valid waiver must be obtained before interrogation may resume. [24] Since Miranda rights are simply a judicial gloss upon the Fifth Amendment which protects against coercive interrogations, the same rule also prevents prosecutors from commenting about the post-arrest silence of suspects who invoke their Miranda rights immediately after arrest.

Finally the remedy is completean involuntary statement cannot be used for any purpose. This similarity is hardly surprising since the federal constitution and many state constitutions had common sources the state constitutions of some of the more important states such as Virginia. While the exact language above is not required by Miranda, the police must advise the suspect that: There is no precise language that must be used in advising a suspect of their Miranda rights. Simply advising the suspect of their rights does not fully comply with the Miranda rule. A common misconception is that a violation of a defendant's constitutional rights warrants dismissal of the charges. 121), the complaint is silent on the Research cases in aggregate with PTAB

anything. (LEXIS 1998) at 306. Coldrey, J. Add-ons include Federal Analytics, Easy Analytics, and the Analytics Workbench.

If you decide to answer questions now without a lawyer present, you have the right to stop answering at any time. Some departments and jurisdictions require that an officer ask "do you understand?" Want to test it first?

[91] A valid Miranda waiver operates as a waiver of Sixth Amendment right. Some states including Virginia require the following sentence, ensuring that the suspect knows that waiving Miranda rights is not a one-time absolute occurrence:[21][22][23]. WebPart 23 Local Rules Hon.

endobj

The consequences of assertion of Sixth Amendment right to counsel are stricter.

endobj Joseph Risi.
For example, "the right to remain silent" means little to a deaf individual and the word "constitutional" may not be understood by people with only an elementary education. Also, access PTAB analytics from this submenu. SurgiSpan is fully adjustable and is available in both static & mobile bays.

The assertion must be specific, detailed, definite and nonconjectural.

Connelly. Luis Gonzalez said, We felt compelled to speak on behalf of the trial judges.

06726 (2013)", Prof. James Duane and Officer George Bruch Fifth Amendment Lecture at Regent University, "U.S. Lawmaker Says Obama Administration Ordered FBI to Read Rights to Detainees", "The Right to Silence: Using American and European Law to Protect a Fundamental Right", "The Right to Silence: Should It Be Curtailed or Abolished?

If you cannot afford a lawyer, one will be appointed for you before any questioning if you wish. The appellate division is composed of four departments. By adding my card, I agree to Docket Alarm's.

court docs.

For example, suppose the police continue with a custodial interrogation after the suspect has asserted his right to silence. During this conversation, the suspect implicated himself in the murder that the undercover agent was investigating.[103]. It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly. 126127. 1993).

The officer is allowed, before asking the suspect a question, to speak at length about evidence collected, witness statements, etc. DEBORAH A. KAPLAN.

Nationwide, there were 181 Retained Pivot Counties and 25 Boomerang Pivot Counties. MAX D'ORAZIO v. BROADWAY 280 PARK FEE LLC. Further, there are no issues of waiver or assertion. 3 0 obj