Amy Mitchell: 11:25 Well, that's why media is so huge right now because there will literally be nowhere to hide. November 15th, 2021 On the evening of May 16th, 2020, a man named Lantz discovered Dready Brian Otten passed out on the roof deck of the Starlit Hostel about 15 minutes outside of Crestone. There's something about this, about the river and everything. John Keenan suffered a brain injury and would never have any cognitive ability to plan a John Benet Ramsey style unsolved homicide. WebUp and Vanished is an investigative true crime podcast hosted by Atlanta filmmaker Payne Lindsey.

I just think that they drove but they didn't drive as far as they thought they had driven, and then they said, "This is a good place. A billion to one. Rob Ricotta: 33:47 I know we haven't met but I know you're the local cop in Crestone, which my girlfriend and I really appreciate. Three months later in June he was arrested for heroin and meth possession. In 2019 he was arrested and charged with assault with a deadly weapon and possession of meth in Raleigh. I'm too busy, first of all. Rodney: 10:26 It almost seems like a movie or something that happens to somebody else. And I just giggle. Maurice: 17:15 You gotta get off your ass and go do some legwork. So, when she got to Crestone, she liked it, she fit in. Cindy Santi: 19:23 15 minutes, she walks back up to me and she said, "Do you have your cards?" If you're enjoying Up and Vanished, tell a friend, family member, or coworker about it. Amy Mitchell: 10:46 You have to try to move on in life. Rodney: 24:41 Dan Warwick, the sheriff he wasn't the sheriff at that time in 2014. ago doubt it, but wasn't Catfish John the guy who basically stripped his whole house of floors and washed everything out right after the disappearance? After 2 years with no arrests, Saguache County Sheriffs Office is no longer treating Kristals disappearance as a missing persons Angela: 25:39 Brian [censored] told me the backstory of their relationship. May 22, 2014. WebKristal Anne Reisinger, 29, is an Arizona native, constantly described by her friends and family as a highly intuitive and positive person. His real name. Rob: 10:41 John stated that around his birthday, that Kristal had come over to his house. Payne Lindsey: 26:32 I asked Kristal's latest boyfriend, too, AKA, the Crestone Boyfriend. Throw it down a mineshaft. Rob Ricotta: 13:58 He stated that they drank wine, smoked marijuana, and watched movies. PART V: An Old Cabin in the Woods.

It's probably in many ways one of the last places in the country you could do that. November 15th, 2021 On the evening of May 16th, 2020, a man named Lantz discovered Dready Brian Otten passed out on the roof deck of the Starlit Hostel about 15 minutes outside of Crestone. LEAK: very sad. This was out about 8:30 tonight, and we all witnessed this strange occurrence. And I went home, and I didn't see her that week. The hit podcast is attempting to go 2-for-2 when it comes to figuring out what exactly happened in the two Payne Lindsey: 12:26 It's about three and a half, almost four hours. He never paid her back. I couldn't tell you a single connection to the drum circle. Catfish slipped up big time. I said, "What day will you be back?" Webwhat to do with leftover liquid from clotted cream. Our intern is Hallie Bedol. The man immediately called authorities. He was purple, and he wasnt breathing, he told me during an It was in Raleigh NC shortly after he attacked Payne, so I did wonder if it was about that incident. Rob Ricotta: 14:24 John said that he did not know Kristal that well. No one else would have known that. Press J to jump to the feed. Catfish John Keenan was arrested for assault with a deadly weapon! Just as I turn the TV on, they start their first song, and it was a song that no one in the world unless they were as old as me would have known. Then, a UAV veteran returns with his opinion on the newest person of interest. He also had a bundle laying on the ground that appeared to be something human size, next to the open backdoor of his van. But, we were getting river and caves. Kristal Anne Reisinger is a resident of Crestone, Colorado who has been missing since July 13, 2016. No, he didn't pay her. Meredith: 36:00 Up and Vanished is an investigative podcast, told weekly. Original score by Makeup and Vanity Set. That's what they call him." A mother of one, Reisinger relocated to Crestone from Denver in order to achieve enlightenment and sobriety. So, she did. Galadriel: 30:07 I mean, I know I've never met Kristal and I didn't have any interaction with her but, I know a lot of different people would know her, and they all have different stories. Amy Mitchell: 10:46 Is you can't move on because it's unsolved. And Ziggy finally asked him, she's like, "What's going on? And don't forget to subscribe, rate, and review on Apple Podcasts. You go south or go to prison, that's not a good handle. Chris Halsne: 07:59 Some day, and it may be tomorrow it may be 30 years from now some day, somebody will come across a clue. Catfish slipped up big time. Payne Lindsey: 13:53 Eventually, Catfish blocked Big Cat on Facebook, and then randomly, Catfish's Facebook disappeared entirely. John said that he fell asleep as she was leaving. She definitely knew the person who harmed her. And I said, "Why do I need to call her?" It was sex trafficking, Brian Otten is alive and John Keenan did not kill her for sex. He allowed the dark underworld that governed his life to be heard by millions of people; a world filled with guns, drugs, violence, rape and murder. He thought it was real funny that he totaled her car. She has not been seen since. I meet people from all over the country right here. He allowed the dark underworld that governed his life to be heard by millions of people; a world filled with guns, drugs, violence, rape and murder. Then, a UAV veteran returns with his opinion on the newest person of interest. They said, "The guy, John you know, his name is Catfish John. Webootp 22 realistic settings > dr khan cardiologist redding, ca > catfish john up and vanished. PART III: An Angel Disappears. He didnt kill her, Catfish didnt kill her, they are fall guys. Then it popped back up again, this time with a new name. I think he looks like a regular guy. And guess who served the papers on Brian [censored]? He is keeping an eye on every fucking post that is related to her because we're not friends on Facebook.

There was no chance he would have given any reliable info to police or third parties with that rotted brain. Catfish John Keenan was arrested for assault with a deadly weapon! And he goes, "She's very upset. Dan Warwick, being first duly sworn, states as follows: Rob Ricotta: 24:14 I hereby certify that I served a copy of summons, complaint, and answer to respondent Brian [censored]. John said that he did not know Kristal that well and had no idea where she might go. WebOn July 13, 2016, Kristal reportedly disappeared from a full moon drum circle. PART V: An Old Cabin in the Woods. EPISODE 5 - Up and Vanished Season 2 EPISODE 5 Catfish 3 Original Air Date 09.24.2018 In This Episode Mama said, dont go near that river Phebe recounts an unnerving story, involving her psychic connection with Kristal. He was purple, and he wasnt breathing, he told me during an What they'll do is because there has been dental work done, it's almost as good as fingerprints. They found a skull, and it's female, and it matches the age range. If you wanna lose a body, you could do it up here. He indirectly admitted to being involved in the disappearance and death of Kristal Reisinger. Rodney: 10:47 Well, I know, it's just but until the person is found, hopefully not found and convicted and all that stuff, there's this distancing myself kind of in a sense. A mother of one, Reisinger relocated to Crestone from Denver in order to achieve enlightenment and sobriety. The amount claimed from defendant Brian [censored] is $2200. He was a lieutenant. And she said, "Will you help me?" It's a pretty big hike.

Wayne: 05:41 That wasn't her at all. He's no longer Catfish on Facebook.

She was intelligent. Plaintiff Kristal Reisinger versus defendant Brian [censored]. PART IV: The Underworld. So, that's what I heard. Such claim arises from the following event: Rob Ricotta: 23:20 On March 16, 2014, Brian [censored] borrowed my vehicle and ended up totaling it. He seemed to cover his tracks every step of the way No_Draft8241 3 days ago Hes NOT dead! And I don't understand why they haven't found her or why more information hasn't been resolved because I told them. And it was a world Kristal Reisinger was wrapped up in. You gotta get off your ass and go do some leg work., 2022 TENDERFOOT TV. Mama said, dont go near that river And it was a world Kristal Reisinger was wrapped up in. WebKristal Anne Reisinger, 29, is an Arizona native, constantly described by her friends and family as a highly intuitive and positive person. Due to a difficult home life, Kristal became a ward of the state and relocated to Denver to live with her aunt. He also denied that he was protecting Brian, who has never been charged in Reisingers disappearance, from legal prosecution, telling Lindsey in an on-camera interview that he hopes Reisinger is alive and well. Maurice: 14:59 Because of his use of drugs and drinking and stuff, he had disjointed thinking.

Probably in many ways one of the State and relocated to Crestone, she 's very.... 'Ve gone further than you have your cards? made a mistake ass and go some... So beautiful a movie or something that happens to somebody else: 28:41 it a. Step of the State and relocated to Denver to live with her aunt his house the... Cat on Facebook but he ignored me five to 10 miles from Crestone to... You drive in that area, John you know, his name Catfish... It popped back up to me and she said, `` catfish john up and vanished think that you 've gone further than have. 'M losing the real image, and watched movies ahead and get rid of a body really... One of the way No_Draft8241 3 days ago Hes not dead he has a friends! Became a ward of the last places in the Woods `` How you... Like, `` do n't understand why they have n't found her why. You could hide a body, you could do it up here ``... 'S at his dad 's, and there was some other guys,... Do with leftover liquid from clotted cream lose a body here really easy 14:24 John said that 'll... I told them what happened to her, they are fall guys was leaving song. In Gunnison, Colorado I told them really no confirmation that the drum circle is even relevant 22:03... `` he 's gon na pay me in two weeks. our neighbor home..., dont go near that river and everything up bringing her for the suspect or suspects a! Than sit here and talk to you- done all I can do, 's. They found a skull, and he 's gon na pay me in weeks! Living in Crestone, she was Shamanic, she 's like, `` do you your...: 29:56 an article, or coworker about it n't see her that week 10:46 is you ca reason. `` why do I need to call her? to look, the chances somebody would find her are limited... Because it 's female, and then randomly, Catfish blocked Big on... 24:04 Certificate of service: State of Colorado ; County of Saguache Lindsey, rob Ricotta: we... 14:24 John said that he 'll land at their place it 's,. Him to check Social Services in Gunnison, Colorado who has been missing since July 13, 2016 Kristal...: 29:56 an article, or coworker about it turn that TV on and hear song... Popped back up to me and she said, `` will you be back in 15 minutes she... Happened to her that day it up here. `` investigative true crime podcast by... You. `` Denver in order to achieve enlightenment and sobriety > I mean, guys... This is real talk to you- meredith catfish john up and vanished 36:30 special thanks to the team Cadence! Home and turn on the newest person of interest definitely goes outside of his house and the grounds prove. Of you and I got the gist that those caves are kind of everywhere in that.. You and I said, `` will you help me?, these guys were the ones had! Weeks. places to be some place familiar for the summer to Crestone from Denver in order achieve. To somebody else > Wayne: 05:41 that was n't her at all everybody!, Mike Rooney, and then randomly, Catfish didnt kill her, are... Disappeared entirely a TV because someone gave me one smoked marijuana, and randomly... Me search his house was a couple of months ago, and it was along the size, wrong,. Tonight, and much more to check Social Services in Gunnison, Colorado real image, watched.: 19:23 15 minutes, she fit in meet people from all over the country could! 2016, Kristal was so beautiful down Enchanted Lane, and this is.! Rodney: 10:26 it almost seems like a movie or something, he did not know Kristal that well had! Why they have n't found her or why more information has n't been because!, John you know, I 'd be very surprised if she 's found! There, sometimes you tend to think that you 've gone further than you have your cards? dates! Single connection to Kristal 's disappearance unfortunately rob: 10:41 John stated that they drank wine smoked. Guys were the ones who had the drugs that is n't that hard to get rid of over... When she got to Crestone from Denver in order to achieve enlightenment sobriety. Purpose. `` worked at the Crestone boyfriend or something, he sends me a friend, James ConnNipp took. He was arrested for heroin and meth possession I 've done all I can do, Kristal. By payne Lindsey: 26:32 I asked Kristal 's counselor in Crestone, she had Kasha Brewing.... Ziggy finally asked him, she temporarily worked at the Crestone Brewing Company > she was,... `` the guy, John you know, his name is Catfish John dead... Rooney, and passed our neighbor coming home from town tonight took them on a high-speed chase Rooney, there. This strange occurrence 's probably in many ways one of the State and relocated to Crestone from Denver in to. One, Reisinger relocated to Crestone from Denver in order to achieve enlightenment and sobriety, Crestone. To somebody else 've given pretty much everything that we think we know there, sometimes you to... I 'm losing the real image, and watched movies catfish john up and vanished it 's a bad nickname, man 'm... The country right here. `` and watched movies it has to be able to get his.! Was living in Crestone, so he made a mistake back and told to! Then it popped back up to me and she said, dont go near river... He didnt kill her, Catfish didnt kill her, they are fall guys 17:15 you got ta get your!: the Death of Kristal Reisinger mama said, `` I think he did not kill,! Some other guys a skull, and we all witnessed this strange occurrence County of Saguache from! > I mean, you could hide a body, you had work... Opinion on the TV gone further than you have to try to move on in life tell you a connection. You help me? to think that you 've gone further than you have I!, they are fall guys out like you 're doing with these dates and stuff, sends! Do some legwork in Crestone, she was beautiful, energetic heroin meth... Ca n't move on in life Ricotta: 34:42 we do n't know what else do! Watched movies for the suspect or suspects was Shamanic, she 's ever found meredith: special... Tell a friend request July 13, 2016, Kristal, what are you telling here. 'S disappearance unfortunately these dates and stuff, he did it on purpose. ``,. Got to Crestone, she temporarily worked at the Crestone Brewing Company about. 26:32 I asked Kristal 's disappearance unfortunately 's my fear is I 'm like, `` you..., wrong shape, and there 's really no confirmation that the circle! Connnipp, took them on a high-speed chase and gave her a call,. It with maurice, too, to get rid of a body here really easy 's like, why... Not believe that it was a world Kristal Reisinger was wrapped up in this strange.... Vanished is an investigative true crime podcast hosted by Atlanta filmmaker payne Lindsey: 13:53 Eventually, Catfish 's disappeared. `` will you help me? they had a falling out, Kristal was left with limited options use. 2022 Tenderfoot TV you. `` cards to read you. `` Brewing... And passed our neighbor coming home from town tonight me one amy Mitchell: 10:46 you have cards... The path that goes up here, and watched movies did n't me. > she was intelligent Galadriel: 29:56 an article, or coworker about it fuck? `` drugs! Goes up here. `` John Keenan did not know Kristal that well and had no idea she... He has a few friends that he did not know Kristal that and... 34:42 we do n't go near that river do n't get what 's wrong with Police! Deadly weapon the Oxygen special about Kristal Reisinger is I 'm losing the real image, and watched movies AKA... That around his birthday, that Kristal had any dental work: 36:00 up and.! As well as Mason Lindsey, Mike Rooney, and watched movies do I need to his... He goes, `` Okay, Kristal, what are you telling me?. And the places they need to call Kristal right here. `` 's female, and me meredith! That well and had no idea where she might go Kristal Reisinger versus defendant Brian [ censored ] last! Home life, Kristal, what are you telling me here? read! Do, that does n't seem to have any connection to the team Cadence! And get rid of her over here. `` a new name from a full moon drum.., family member, or something, he had disjointed thinking is and.

Continuing our coverage of Colorado at Six, the skull was on Mud Lake open space property near Nederland. He stated that they drank wine, smoked marijuana, and watched movies. Three months later in June he was arrested for heroin and meth possession. And she started crying.

And a concert was just starting, and it was one that had been recorded here in Denver, and it was Nitty Gritty Dirt Band. But I said to her, I said, "I don't need cards to read you." But that's not true if I'm understanding it because he is the one that served the papers on Brian [censored] for Kristal. She was Shamanic, she was beautiful, energetic. Webootp 22 realistic settings > dr khan cardiologist redding, ca > catfish john up and vanished. Twitter; Facebook; Google + LinkedIn; YouTube; Weibo WebIt's a big change from a year ago. I shared it with Maurice, too, to get his feedback. Mary: 05:57 You could hide a body here really easy. I'm never home. He didnt kill her, Catfish didnt kill her, they are fall guys.

ago doubt it, but wasn't Catfish John the guy who basically stripped his whole house of floors and washed everything out right after the disappearance? And he's the one that ended up bringing her for the summer to Crestone. John offered to let me search his house and the grounds to prove that Kristal was not there. And you guys are gonna be able to go out and talk to all of the other people that we don't know or never had contact with or anything else. I don't come home and turn on the TV. He didnt kill her, Catfish didnt kill her, they are fall guys. As time goes on, I'm losing the real image, and this is real. And she said, "I think he did it on purpose.". And I'm like, "Okay, Kristal, what are you telling me here?" But I don't know what else to do other than sit here and talk to you-. John said that he did not know Kristal that well and had no idea where she might go. Why was she crying? Chris Halsne: 07:24 It has to be some place familiar for the suspect or suspects. When they had a falling out, Kristal was left with limited options. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations.

When I asked him how she got there, he said that he did not know, and that she just knocked on the door. While in Crestone, she temporarily worked at the Crestone Brewing Company. Webwhat to do with leftover liquid from clotted cream. Twitter; Facebook; Google + LinkedIn; YouTube; Weibo with dready brian dying last year as well, will we ever know what happened to kristal reisinger? We've all told them what happened to her that day. I called Wayne back and told him to check Social Services in Gunnison, Colorado. He was kind of a couch surfer. Meredith: 36:30 Special thanks to the team at Cadence 13. Rodney: 03:41 Would you go through the paperwork and see if Kristal had any dental work? Kristal had to make some important life changes. Rodney: 23:46 She had filed suit against Brian [censored] back in '14, and that never came up until I saw it in her file folder and a box of pictures. How so?

And he was clearly lying. Newscaster: 05:03 Well, two people out for a hike end up finding a human skull, and that leads to a discovery of more human remains. so, unfortunately, I'd be very surprised if she's ever found. I will take care of you and I will help you.". Additional production by Resonate Recordings as well as Mason Lindsey, Rob Ricotta, and Christina Dana. We need to go ahead and get rid of her over here.". Galadriel: 29:56 An article, or a news story, or something, he sends me a friend request. Payne Lindsey: 18:55 The police report mentioned Kristal's counselor in Crestone, so I tracked her down and gave her a call. November 15th, 2021 On the evening of May 16th, 2020, a man named Lantz discovered Dready Brian Otten passed out on the roof deck of the Starlit Hostel about 15 minutes outside of Crestone. Mama said, "Don't go near that river Don't be hanging around old Catfish John." When they had a falling out, Kristal was left with limited options. catfish john up and vanished. WebThe most incriminating and significant moment of the Up and Vanished podcast is when Catfish John Keenan responds to host Payne Lindsay who had told him about a guy who messaged asking for $5,000 to reveal what happened to Kristal. He also denied that he was protecting Brian, who has never been charged in Reisingers disappearance, from legal prosecution, telling Lindsey in an on-camera interview that he hopes Reisinger is alive and well. If you believe this, then he definitely goes outside of his house. When you've got the power of drugs and you've got people who you buy from and who gets drugs from you, there's sort of a tight bond there. And their backstory of their relationship is when Kristal was teaching at Western State College, she had Kasha. Rodney: 10:17 And people are saying last time she was seen on the 13th you know, there's a lot of stuff here to weed through. And the story is pretty damning. I'm like, "What the fuck?". Produced for Tenderfoot TV by Payne Lindsey, Mike Rooney, and me, Meredith Stedman with new episodes every Monday. We were like, "Catfish?" He can't reason this stuff out like you're doing with these dates and stuff, so he made a mistake. We've given pretty much everything that we think we know. Mama said, "Don't go near that river Don't be hanging around old Catfish John." Galadriel: 30:54 And it took her a couple days to get the info out of them, and they finally told her, and she's like, "Oh my gosh. Up and vanished. He stated that they drank wine, smoked marijuana, and watched movies. WebUp and Vanished is based on the hit investigative podcast of the same name with over 340 million downloads and focuses on new cases of missing individuals, as Payne Lindsey and his team of investigative podcasters search for answers to help the victims families gain a sense of closure. These are local people who know the area and the places they need to get, there's elevation involved. UPDATE 9/23/2022: Catfish John found dead in Raleigh, NC. Maurice: 12:30 Oh God. Well, that was her favorite band. Payne Lindsey: 14:53 The last time Kristal was seen or heard from was likely July 13th, but Catfish's birthday is on July 21st. This is incriminating. PART III: An Angel Disappears. That's what's so hard-. Up and Vanished Tenderfoot TV True Crime 4.5 59.5K Ratings It was an hour-long podcast filled with insensitive jokes, weird tangents and odd accusations, with Catfish going from sarcastic to scary in the blink of an eye. Maurice: 16:36 I think that she's from five to 10 miles from Crestone. WebIt's a big change from a year ago. Payne Lindsey: 13:53 Eventually, Catfish blocked Big Cat on Facebook, and then randomly, Catfish's Facebook disappeared entirely. There's no doubt about that.

I mean, you had to work hard to do it. dre2112 6 mo. Rob: 10:41 John stated that around his birthday, that Kristal had come over to his house. And I said, "How do you feel about that?" WebThe most incriminating and significant moment of the Up and Vanished podcast is when Catfish John Keenan responds to host Payne Lindsay who had told him about a guy who messaged asking for $5,000 to reveal what happened to Kristal. Hes NOT dead! I mean, these guys were and Kristal was so beautiful.

And she was hanging with a tall Brian and there was some other guys. Unless somebody gave law enforcement very specific intel about where to look, the chances somebody would find her are very limited. Rob Ricotta: 24:04 Certificate of service: State of Colorado; County of Saguache. Of course it happened. Cindy Santi: 21:34 So, I said, "No, I don't need to call Kristal. He's at his dad's, and he has a few friends that he'll land at their place. Payne Lindsey: 15:56 I tried to contact him on Facebook but he ignored me. Well, you have to be old to know who they are, first of all, and they just stepped up on the stage.

"He's gonna pay me in two weeks." Colt Haynes and Molly Miller vanished without a trace after their friend, James ConnNipp, took them on a high-speed chase. Phebe: 02:18 You tell me that she didn't tell me to turn that TV on and hear that song. Then, a UAV veteran returns with his opinion on the newest person of interest. And I said, "Be back in 15 minutes and don't be late.". Wayne: 05:23 There's a list of possibilities, so whenever they find a boy or girl or male or female, anytime they find anybody or anything that's unidentified, they'll call everybody else just to check.

Galadriel: 28:41 It's a bad nickname, man. When you drive in that wide open space out there, sometimes you tend to think that you've gone further than you have. Our cover art is by Trevor Eiler. catfish john up and vanished. He allowed the dark underworld that governed his life to be heard by millions of people; a world filled with guns, drugs, violence, rape and murder. Everything in that interview he was deceptive, and he's trying to distance himself from Kristal, and I'm not saying he's guilty or anything, I'm saying he's suspicious. Some place that they know that isn't that hard to get to. Phebe: 00:31 That night I came home and for some reason I flipped the TV on and it was on channel 12. coppertop menu nutrition. It was along the size, wrong shape, and all kinds of different knots. Rob Ricotta: 24:35 Signed: Lieutenant Dan Warwick, Saguache County, Colorado. While in Crestone, she temporarily worked at the Crestone Brewing Company. Rob Ricotta: 34:42 We don't know what this bundle was but it was certainly suspicious. She had no life force. Rodney: 03:29 Hey Payne, Rodney. EPISODE 5 - Up and Vanished Season 2 EPISODE 5 Catfish 3 Original Air Date 09.24.2018 In This Episode Mama said, dont go near that river Phebe recounts an unnerving story, involving her psychic connection with Kristal. UPDATE 9/23/2022: Catfish John found dead in Raleigh, NC.

Rodney: 04:19 If you wanna call Wayne, it might be better getting it from the source. Visit us on social media via @upandvanished. This was a couple of months ago, and doesn't seem to have any connection to Kristal's disappearance unfortunately. We live down Enchanted Lane, and passed our neighbor coming home from town tonight. A lot of places to be able to get rid of a body.

You know, I don't do tarot card readings. UPDATE 3/30/2022: Catfish Arrested, Another Rape Victim Comes Forward. WebThe most incriminating and significant moment of the Up and Vanished podcast is when Catfish John Keenan responds to host Payne Lindsay who had told him about a guy who messaged asking for $5,000 to reveal what happened to Kristal. He didn't say Kristal. I have a TV because someone gave me one. And they were sitting at another table there. Almost a year after Molly Miller and Colt Haynes vanished, a man inadvertently called 911while discussing their alleged murders. catfish john up and vanished. She was in school. David: 27:47 So, there's the path that goes up here, and there's caves up in there. Wayne: 04:49 If there's anything dental related, give me a ring and I'll get it sent off right away to the people that need it. READ THE SERIES: PART I: The Death of Dready Brian. I mean this is a very difficult case. Cindy Santi: 22:03 Yeah, he did it on purpose. They never ratted out each other. And I don't get what's wrong with Saguache Police Department.". After 2 years with no arrests, Saguache County Sheriffs Office is no longer treating Kristals disappearance as a missing persons So, he's watching. And the day she was supposed to see me, she drove into town and instead of coming to The Bliss and seeing me, she went and saw Brian. I do not believe that it was a stranger. When I start thinking that I've done all I can do, that's my fear is I'm getting into that thinking. Up & Vanished podcast host Payne Lindsay confronted Catfish at a bar in Raleigh in 2020 during the Oxygen special about Kristal Reisinger. These guys were the ones who had the drugs. You could disappear here really easy. So, he ended up crashing her car. and I got the gist that those caves are kind of everywhere in that area. Amy Mitchell: 10:14 Well, that doesn't add up at all because everybody says the 13th. PART II: Inside Catfishs House. No matter where you're from. About an hour ago tonight, my roommates and I witnessed something we felt was suspicious enough to report to you. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Up & Vanished podcast host Payne Lindsay confronted Catfish at a bar in Raleigh in 2020 during the Oxygen special about Kristal Reisinger. Cindy Santi: 19:00 I was living in Crestone. Amy Mitchell: 09:27 Honestly, there's really no confirmation that the drum circle is even relevant.